Table 1 shows one common service brakes related problems of the 2026 BMW X5.
| Problem Category | Number of Problems |
|---|---|
| Service Brakes problems |
On [xxx] as I was driving on [xxx] in FL and got in to some traffic I noticed the car was shuddering a bit when I braked and I could here metal against metal coming from the brakes. I called sixt 800 number and spoke to a gentleman at their call center in asia. He asked me why I needed brakes . I was shocked at his response , needless to say. He told me he reported it and I needed to return the car in miami at the airport . I spent the night in jupiter as it was around 5 pm. The next day [xxx] I drove the car to the mia airport where it was exchanged for a new car. Information redacted pursuant to the freedom of information act (foia), 5 u. S. C. 552(b)(6).
My 2026 BMW X5 xdrive50e experienced a serious freeway safety event involving loss of braking/brake power, loss of vehicle power/functionality, and multiple vehicle warnings/errors. The incident occurred while I was driving on the freeway and substantially affected my ability to safely operate the vehicle. BMW emergency services subsequently towed the vehicle to irvine BMW on 07/09/2026. Irvine BMW later attributed the event to emergency stop assist (esa) and the driver monitoring system (dms), rather than identifying a mechanical brake failure. Its written explanation states that esa can take over vehicle guidance and decelerate the vehicle using multiple short braking jolts. The dealership reported a stored dms fault but stated that it could not duplicate my reported condition. I have not been provided evidence that the original freeway event was reproduced or that its cause was conclusively established. Irvine BMW initially represented that material covering the display was an aftermarket screen protector and stated that BMW technical required its removal because it could interfere with the dms camera. On 07/27/2026, the general manager apologized and confirmed that the material was actually original BMW transportation protection film. The dealership also proposed reducing esa sensitivity as an alternative. I remain concerned that the combination of loss of braking/brake power, loss of vehicle power/functionality, and the reported esa/dms behavior may represent a serious safety defect or malfunction affecting braking, vehicle control, or driver-monitoring systems. I kindly request that NHTSA review this reported safety event, including esa, dms, related vehicle-control systems, and the interaction with the display/driver-monitoring system, and determine whether further investigation is warranted. I can provide dealership records, BMW app data, communications, and diagnostic documents.