Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator Problems of Jeep Wrangler

Jeep Wrangler owners have reported 9 problems related to automatic transmission gear indicator (under the power train category). The most recently reported issues are listed below. Also please check out the statistics and reliability analysis of Jeep Wrangler based on all problems reported for the Wrangler.

1 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 2024 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 10/14/2025

Year: 2024 make & model: Jeep Wrangler 4-door 4xe body style: sahara 4x4 VIN: 1c4rjxp60rw278656 on October 14, 2025, I began to drive my car home. After the use of the brakes, while I was pulling out of a large parking lot, the car functionally went into neutral, the “d” on prndl display began to blink. The brakes worked. I pulled over, put the car into park and then into drive again. Still, no change. I turned the car on and off and put it into drive and the car began to drive normally, until I reached a stop light, exiting the parking lot. Then, the same thing occurred. The “d” began blinking and the car was unresponsive to the accelerator. I turned off and re-started the car. Again, it drove fine. The “d” was lit, but didn’t blink. I was driving very slowly and then went down a hill. As soon as I tapped the brakes, the same thing occurred again. I was only 6 miles or less from the dealership. So, after re-starting the car for the 3rd or 4th time, I learned that using the parking brake did not disrupt the car and the accelerator continued to work. I drove to the dealership’s service department and used the parking brake when I needed to slow down. Today is 10/18/2025. I received a call back on 10/16 and none since. Today, I drove out to the service department and talked directly to a manager, who was vague on the car’s status.

See all problems of the 2024 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

2 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 2014 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 10/23/2019

2014 Jeep Wrangler unlimited. Consumer writes in regard to gear stick moving/slipping while engine is running. The consumer stated the failure occurs on a daily basis. The warranty company could not duplicate the failure so, was unable to repair the vehicle.

See all problems of the 2014 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

3 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 2018 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 07/09/2018

While starting the vehicle for the third time in two days after picking up the car following a pcm flash for a cruise control recall, I noticed the prnd lights flashing on the shiftier approximately 10 seconds after vehicle start. I subsequently received a cel and a "service shifter' message. I shut off the vehicle, let all displays go dark, and restarted; the cel went away. I proceeded to continue my drive home. About 10/15 min later, I noticed the lights flickering once again on the shifter. I once again elected to continue home as it was late at night. Approximately 2/3 miles later, I received errors on the start/stop and traction control systems. The vehicle appeared to go into a "limp mode" - I it would not shift out of 8th gear and I experienced reduced power and an inability to maintain the posted 70 mph. I decided to exit at the next off-ramp as I could maintain 65mph. While exiting, I noticed the gauge needles (speedo and tach) sweep and got airbag warnings. I heard the electric fan go 100% high (very loud) and I lost power steering. I pulled over to the side of the road and shut off the vehicle. After letting it sit for approximately 5 min, I restarted the vehicle and while the cel remained no other errors were illuminated or presented. I was less than 2 miles from a Jeep dealer and decided to try to continue there on access roads. About 1/8 mile down the road, I once again lost power steering and say various error messages like before. I pulled into a parking lot and aborted my attempts and called for a tow to the dealer less than a mile away. Posted are pictures of the errors read using an obd-2 scanner I had in the glove compartment. While I have driven cars without power steering in the past, it was rather difficult with the larger ~32" tires and I am not sure a crash could be prevented if a smaller person was driving.

See all problems of the 2018 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

4 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 2010 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 03/07/2013

I am having major problems with over drive shaking and not running right at all. My Jeep will kick itself in netrual and flash the prndl lights kickthe check engine light on when you are driving. S done it at bad intersections trying to pull across the high way. I have had to a service shop and talked to many people trying to figure out what to do. It does not need a rebuild. So please give me info on any help what to try before it gets me killed. It is getting very dangerous!.

See all problems of the 2010 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

5 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 2004 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 12/01/2007

Automatic transmission would not shift to park - unable to remove key from ignition - taken to the Jeep dealership and told them the same problem with the same transmission 42rle was recalled in 2005 Wranglers and I wanted to know why the 2004 Wranglers were not part of the same recall when we are dealing with the same transmission - the vehicle has less than 22,000 miles - the 2005 Wrangler recall number is 05v460000: a/t parking pawl shaft anchoring and recall - a/t parking pawl cup plug defect - safety recall e14.

See all problems of the 2004 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

6 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 1998 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 03/31/2002

The consumer state the his son had a problem with the transmission staying in gear. The consumer(s) are requesting to be reimbursed for the repair costs. Scc.

See all problems of the 1998 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

7 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 1999 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 04/30/2001

While driving gear shift came completely out of transmission. Dealer need3e it. Retainer spring had popped out of position. Please provide any further details.

See all problems of the 1999 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

8 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 1997 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 10/01/1998

Gear shifter came out of its housing as the car was being driven, due to weak lock, replacement of both upper and lower level shifter.

See all problems of the 1997 Jeep Wrangler 🔎.

9 Automatic Transmission Gear Indicator problem of the 1997 Jeep Wrangler

Failure Date: 06/08/1998

While driving about 30 mph and shifting gears, the gear shift came off in driver's hand, causing driver to lose control of the vehicle. Owner experienced this problem 3 other times. All times the part was repaired by the dealership.




Wrangler Service Bulletins
Wrangler Safety Recalls
Wrangler Defect Investigations